Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office Siphons Budget Surpluses for Large Employee Bonuses

According to employee bonus letters acquired by Reconstructing Dayton through a public records request, Montgomery County employees receive large bonuses at the end of each year with money that would otherwise go back to the county. These are not normal sized bonuses. For the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s office, they range from $4,679.98 to $23,405.24 given to 125 employees in 2019 and all 119 employees in 2020. 2019 bonuses averaged $8,348 and 2020 bonuses averaged $8,851.35. In 2019, the bonuses equaled 9.0% to 21.6% of employee salaries, with an average bonus of 15.4% of an employee’s annual salary.

For the 2020 bonus letters, County Prosecutor Mat Heck wrote that, “As a result of the ongoing economic conditions created by the unprecedented slow down or shut down of many business, and the resulting reduction of tax revenues, the Board of the County Commissioners determined it was necessary to both reduce all county budgets for 2021 by 3.0% and to not authorize any pay raises for 2021.”

The austerity measures Mr. Heck writes of are somewhat reflected in the year-end bonuses. The Prosecutor’s office spent $1,043,543.91 on bonuses in 2019 and $1,053,310.59 in 2020, despite handing bonuses out to fewer individuals in 2020. While it is true that no pay raises were given during 2020, a quick comparison of the numbers reveals that 2020 bonuses were increased to partially compensate for the lack of raises. In some cases, the 2020 bonus exceeded the total 2019 bonus and pay raise combined. For example, in 2019, Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Jamie Rizzo received a $4,987.42 bonus and a $1,312.48 pay raise. In 2020, Rizzo received an $8,017.63 bonus, $1,717.73 more than his 2019 bonus and pay raise combined.

2019 Prosecutor Office Bonuses & Raises

wdt_ID Name Salary Bonus Raise
1 Adkinson, Ashley 55,952.00 8,560.66 1,398.80
2 Ahearn, Todd 79,768.00 11,646.13 1,994.20
3 Albanese, Sharalie 30,992.00 5,051.70 1,000.00
4 Allen, Michael 55,161.60 8,219.08 1,379.04
5 Amarante, John 78,873.60 11,752.17 1,971.84
6 Amos, John 89,044.80 15,404.75 2,226.12
7 Amrhein, Nicole 60,881.60 9,801.94 1,522.04
8 Armanini, Debra 151,216.00 21,775.10 3,780.40
9 Arnold, Carly 30,992.00 5,051.70 1,000.00
10 Bakosh, Hannah 35,505.60 4,935.28 1,000.00
11 Barrentine, Ward 89,689.60 13,543.13 2,242.24
12 Brandt, Daniel 93,849.60 15,391.33 2,346.24
13 Brodbeck, Thomas 55,161.60 8,605.21 1,379.04
14 Bruder, Lisa 61,505.60 10,025.41 1,537.64
15 Carper, Margaret 80,683.20 11,779.75 2,017.08
16 Carson, Kelsie 57,948.80 8,808.22 1,448.72
17 Chaille, Nancie 43,087.60 6,550.84 1,077.44
18 Claypoole, Erin 88,857.60 15,372.36 2,221.44
19 Clift, Karen 43,929.60 6,501.58 1,098.24
20 Clutter, Dianna 35,817.60 5,515.92 1,000.00
21 Comes, Jennifer 23,004.80 4,692.98 1,000.00
22 Crear, Candace 58,926.40 8,190.77 1,473.16
23 Creekmore, Holly 32,760.00 5,077.80 1,000.00
24 Crim, Whitney 54,828.80 8,991.92 1,370.72
25 Daidone, Leon 131,331.20 17,992.37 3,283.28
Name Salary Bonus Raise

The bonuses alone do not reflect the austerity measure of a 3.0% reduction in expenses, but a total reduction in payroll likely achieves that number. This is because of a reduction in staff as every 2020 employee listed on the Prosecutor’s Staff Directory received a bonus letter except Mat Heck, the author of the letters. Regardless, the bonus structure of the Prosecutor’s office appears to be a way for county employees to pocket cash that would normally be returned to taxpayers.

Although it is not uncommon for Christmas bonuses in the private sector to equal a single month’s pay, that would make the average bonus in 2019 only $4,522.05. That is significantly lower than the average of $8,348.35 Mr. Heck actually handed out to his employees.

First Assistant Prosecutor Debra Armanini received the largest bonuses and pay raises. In 2019 Armanini received a bonus of $21,775.10 and a pay raise of $3,780.40 in addition to her $151,216.00 salary. The lowest pay raises in 2019 equaled $1,000, which appears to be the standard pay raise for an employee making less than $40,000.

2020 Prosecutor Office Bonuses

wdt_ID Name Bonus
1 Adkinson, Ashley 8,831.22
2 Ahearn, Todd 12,591.78
3 Allen, Michael 8,423.63
4 Amarante, John 12,369.99
5 Amos, John 15,424.70
6 Amrhein, Nicole 9,734.40
7 Armanini, Debra 23,405.24
8 Arnold, Carly 5,022.49
9 Bakosh, Hannah 6,607.22
10 Barrentine, Ward 14,525.89
11 Brandt, Daniel 15,392.00
12 Brodbeck, Thomas 8,423.63
13 Bruder, Lisa 10,339.35
14 Carper, Margaret 12,653.22
15 Carson, Kelsie 9,439.87
16 Chaille, Nancie 6,715.24
17 Claypoole, Erin 14,846.56
18 Clift, Karen 8,285.89
19 Clutter, Dianna 5,669.66
20 Comes, Jennifer 4,709.00
21 Crear, Candace 9,000.08
22 Creekmore, Holly 5,198.79
23 Crim, Whitney 9,160.86
24 Daidone, Leon 18,038.76
25 DeRosa, Matthew 8,812.00
Name Bonus

Public records requests for other county offices are pending to reveal what other county offices provide large bonuses with surplus funds. Sources have told us this activity extends beyond the prosecutor’s office, but at the time of publication we have not acquired evidence from other county offices. Although we also placed public records requests on November 25th to the County Engineer, Dayton & Montgomery County Public Health, Montgomery County Job and Family Services, and the Montgomery County Auditor’s Office, only the Prosecutor’s office has complied with our request. The Montgomery County Auditor’s Office responded to our request and promised to comply in the next week or so. This week we have also sent additional requests to the Montgomery County Treasurer’s Office and the Montgomery County Clerk of Courts.

Our sources tell us that this bonus scheme by the county is pervasive. The legality of the bonus scheme is dubious and we are conferring with lawyers to determine whether it violates the letter or just the spirit of the law. The Ohio Revised Code does include language pertaining to the mismanagement of public funds. If you work for the county government and you would like to provide a statement or act as a whistleblower, please contact us. We will keep any sources confidential. If you are a lawyer and would like to provide a pro-bono analysis of this issue, we would also love to hear from you.

If you would like to receive future updates regarding our investigation, please input your e-mail below. We do not sell information and we will not send you any spam—you’ll just receive a reminder e-mail whenever a new post is published on this site. In the next couple of days we will have more information about this story as we receive more public records and analyze the data we have already compiled. Just a cursory look at the data so far has revealed some interesting correlations between high bonus individuals and political influence. It will require a full report.

Also please consider donating to help support investigative reporting to keep our local government officials accountable.

Just the facts:

  • Average pay increase (bonus + raises) 2019 = $9,748.99
  • Average bonus 2019 = $8,348.35
  • Average bonus 2020 = $8,851.35
  • Payroll (according to letters) 2019 = $6,783,082
  • Payroll + bonuses (according to letters) 2019 = $7,826,625.91
  • Average salary (2019) = $54,264.65
  • 3% of above # = $234,798.78
  • Bonuses 2019 = $1,043,543.91
  • Bonuses + Raises (2019) = $1,218,624.21
  • Bonuses 2020 = $1,053,310.59
  • Difference between 2019/2020 = $9,766.68

2019 Bonus Letters


2020 Bonus Letters



  1. Mike Bock

    I appreciate the work you do to inform the public.

    • Alexander Sharp

      Thanks, Mike. There’s more to this story yet to come.



  1. Reconstructing Dayton unearths county corruption in the prosecutors office | Esrati - […] an anonymous tip to this site, Reconstructing Dayton, a 501(c)(4) nonprofit, has revealed that the Montgomery County’s Prosecutor’s Office…
  2. Heck Uses Bonuses to Circumvent Ohio Administrative Code | Reconstructing Dayton - […] coverage of the bonus scandal from the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office, we first looked at how Mat Heck has…
  3. The Inefficiencies of the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office: A Deeper Look at Bonuses | Reconstructing Dayton - […] the large bonuses handed out by Montgomery County Prosecutor Mat Heck, we previously looked at the initial findings of…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other posts you might like

Get the latest news to your inbox.