Mailer sent to Precinct Captains for the 2026 Montgomery County Democratic Party (Ohio)

On Jun 25 2026, the newly elected Montgomery County Democratic Party precinct captains can vote to adopt a minor revision of a dysfunctional constitution, or introduce and adopt a reform model based upon the one in use by the Butler County Democrats.

The new party leadership refuses to use their own communications channels to inform the precinct captains of this option. That's why Reconstructing Dayton funded a mailer, and made both versions available here for comment.

The MCDP Minutes are missing a few...

If you read the Organizational Meeting minutes, there is ZERO mention of David Esrati's contribution of a "Reform Constitution" option.  We have video to know he did.
The party moved to vote on a constitution on Jun 25th, yet, only presented their version.
In the agenda, no mention is made of any other option.

This is not democracy. This is why Phil Plummer is running unopposed. Our party is dysfunctional. You have a choice to change that.

A "Decision Sheet" for the Constitution

To help spell things out, there will be a decision sheet handed out. It outlines the 2 paths we can take.
Delay and play with the words of a constitution that does nothing to move us forward.
Or adopt a constitution that comes with a playbook to win.

Which side are you on?

The Proposed 2026 Official MCDP Constitution

This was sent out by email on 19 Jun 2026. It is essentially the same as the 2022 Constitution. Our Chair says only editors can see the updates. So, they sent out a version the executive committee can't review.

This is embarrassing.

After a bunch of messages, I finally got this version. "The Redline"

 

What changed?

The Constitution Committee did make several substantive changes following the listening session.

Members would now receive at least 30 days to review a proposed constitution before voting on it. The party would announce its six regular Executive Committee meetings by January 1, post them online, and provide proposed agendas with notices for both regular and special meetings.

The draft replaces the old “those present and voting” quorum with a quorum equal to 10% of the elected Central Committee. It also adds Robert’s Rules of Order as the party’s parliamentary authority.

Automatic Executive Committee membership would be expanded to include all Democratic mayors and all Democratic city council and city commission members in Montgomery County.

The endorsement section was substantially rewritten. Screening committees would have between six and twelve members, candidates would receive questionnaires, and the committee would provide the Executive Committee with a written summary of its findings and recommendations. State-party neutrality would bind the county party in state races, and the draft adds detailed procedures for incumbent, challenger and open-seat endorsements.

The committee structure was also changed. A Labor Liaison Committee was added. Screening, Auditing and Rules were moved into an ad hoc category, while standing committee chairs would be required to submit regular written reports, annual priorities and year-end accomplishment reports. Committee-chair names would be posted on the party website.

Precinct captains would receive an orientation, and the bylaws now list basic responsibilities for Central and Executive Committee members, including attending meetings, organizing precincts, registering voters, participating in party events and supporting Democratic candidates.

The draft also formally identifies the recognized Democratic clubs and requires the party chair to meet with their presidents quarterly and report back to the Executive Committee.

Those are the significant changes that appear to have come out of the listening-session process.

WHAT YOU SHOULD VOTE FOR ON JUNE 25TH

The Proposed Reform Constitution

Two constitutions. Two very different ideas of what a political party should be.

The committee’s final draft makes some procedural improvements, but it remains fundamentally a command-and-control document. Power still flows from the chair and Executive Committee. Screening remains appointed. Incumbents receive special protection. Ordinary Democrats are welcome in theory, but the document gives them few meaningful roles, little authority and no clear path to help build the party.

The Reform Constitution starts with a different question: what structure will help us elect more Democrats?

It opens the tent. Every Democrat can participate. Precinct captains are expected to build teams with assistant captains, block captains, apartment contacts, volunteers and future candidates. Clubs, labor, caucuses, neighborhood organizations and allied groups become organizing partners instead of spectators.

It creates the machinery we need now: regular training, regional support, candidate recruitment, a yearly candidate academy, campaign field coordination, voter registration, canvassing, literature delivery, ballot cure, GOTV and party-owned data that does not disappear when a candidate, consultant or chair leaves.

It also creates accountability. Major votes are recorded. Agendas must identify substantive actions in advance. Committee chairs report what they plan to do and what they accomplished. Precinct activity is measured. Vacancies, voter contact, training, volunteer recruitment and data return are tracked. Officers and appointed members are expected to do the work, not merely hold titles.

Most important, the Reform Constitution answers what we heard at the listening session. People asked how to participate, how to train precinct captains, how to recruit volunteers, how to develop candidates, how to improve communications, how to share data and how to hold leadership accountable.

The committee draft offers better rules for running meetings.

The Reform Constitution gives us marching orders for winning elections.

It does not have to be perfect forever. It contains a clear process for review and amendment. But it is ready to put people to work now, while the November election is approaching and five Montgomery County judgeships could be decided for a generation.

We can keep debating structure while the calendar runs out, or we can adopt the Reform Constitution and start building the party we need.

Vote Reform. Build the team. Win elections.

There comes a point where process becomes procrastination.

We have compared the drafts. We have marked them up. We have talked about structure, quorum, endorsements, committees, precinct captains, training, data, vacancies, and accountability.

That work matters.

But there is an election in November.

Montgomery County Democrats do not have the luxury of spending the summer perfecting a governing document while the actual work of organizing waits for permission.

If we keep revising the existing draft, nothing meaningful gets put in motion. We will keep meeting. We will keep discussing. We will keep debating who controls what. And November will keep coming.

If we adopt the Reform Constitution now, we have marching orders.

Not theory. Work.

Fill precinct vacancies. Recruit assistant precinct captains. Train people. Build precinct teams. Organize data. Identify volunteers. Recruit candidates. Support campaigns. Coordinate field work. Track progress. Report back. Learn from what happens. Improve the rules annually.

And just as important: invite people in.

That may be the biggest difference.

The old culture says: if you are not elected, you do not belong in the room.

The reform model says: if you are willing to work, there is a place for you.

Every precinct captain should be building a team — assistant captains, block captains, apartment contacts, senior housing contacts, student contacts, union contacts, neighborhood volunteers, donors, drivers, callers, door knockers, sign location finders, sign deliverers, email gatherers, and future candidates.

Our meetings should not just be where people sit and listen to reports from the top.

They should be where precinct teams show what they have done: doors knocked, calls made, voters contacted, emails collected, volunteers recruited, dollars raised, literature delivered, candidate leads found, and problems solved.

That is how you build a party. Not by guarding the door. By opening it.

The Reform Constitution does not pretend to be perfect forever. In fact, one of its strengths is that it creates a better mechanism to amend, review, and improve the rules every year with notice, member participation, and public accountability.

But it is strong enough to start.

And starting matters.

We have five judgeships in Montgomery County that may be filled for thirty years or more. If we lose them now, we may not get another chance for a generation. We have State Representative races that matter. We have to help turn Ohio at least purple again. We have to build the local Democratic infrastructure that state and national candidates can actually use.

That will not happen by accident.

It will not happen because we adopted a constitution that preserves the old habits with cleaner language.

It will happen only if the party decides that precinct organizing, candidate recruitment, voter contact, training, data, grassroots fundraising, transparency, participation, and accountability are not optional side projects. They are the job.

The Reform Constitution makes them the job.

A county party that wants to win cannot be built around who gets endorsed in a room. It has to be built precinct by precinct, voter by voter, volunteer by volunteer, candidate by candidate, year round. Primary elections decide who the people want, not a few of us in a back room.

That is what this vote is really about.

Not whether every comma is perfect.

Not whether every person got every word they wanted.

Not whether we can imagine more revisions in August.

The question is whether we are ready to move from talking about reform to operating like a party that intends to win.

Read both drafts.

Compare what each one actually does.

Then show up and vote for the constitution that gives us work to do now.

Vote for the Reform Constitution.

Let’s move forward and build the machine we need — an open, working, precinct-based Democratic Party that recognizes the people doing the work and gives everyone willing to help a way to lead.

And if you have a problem with something in the reform version you want to fix, leave a comment, and we'll see if we can adopt it asap!

2 Comments

  1. David Esrati

    Comments weren’t working until 11 am on Jun 25- sorry.

    Reply
  2. David Esrati

    Apparently, any mention of this effort or a Reform Constitution is forbidden by Robert and his Rules.
    Not a single Precinct Captain suggested bringing the reform constitution to the floor for discussion or a vote.
    It’s still a top down organization.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *